Channel 5 Register | Sign in |
 
 

Mini HatchbackAugust 2010

Recommended.

The mid-life facelift does little to change the Mini's looks, but it does improve the diesel engines and add some equipment.

Our rating:

4

User rating:

5
Mini Hatchback
 
 

Fifth Gear Mini Hatchback review

 
 
1. Brilliant to drive
2. Cheap to run and holds its value like no other
3. Still one of the best in the class

WE DON'T LIKE

1. Styling tired after all this time
2. Poor rear seat space
3. Expensive to buy compared to rivals
 
 

When Mini brought out the second generation of its small hatchback in 2006, casual observers were hard pushed to see what had changed from the original version of the BMW-made supermini.

This mid-life facelift doesn't advance the car's styling much further either. There are subtle changes to the grille, bumpers and light clusters, but even with pre and post-facelift models next to one another it is hard to see the difference.

However, things have changed under the skin. The diesel engines are the biggest beneficiaries of the mid-life refresh. CO2 emissions have now been dropped to below 100g/km for the hatchback model, with the Clubman and Cabriolet versions not far behind. The petrols remain unchanged, with five power options on offer, starting with the Mini First and heading up to the flagship John Cooper Works.

The facelift doesn't alter the dimensions of the cars, so the hatchback remains a relatively impractical car for any more than two adults. It is possible to squeeze a passenger in the rear, but not without compromising front footwell space. The Clubman offers fractionally more room, but is by no means a practical estate as its chunkier image might imply. The facelift leaves the rear-hinged half door that provides access to the back seats on the right hand side, so still the wrong side for access from UK pavements. The boot is accessed by a pair of cupboard-style doors that provide easy access to the storage space but compromise the rear visibility thanks to the black line down the centre that door connection brings.

The Cabriolet is even more compromised in terms of practicality, with access to a small boot through a small letter-box style opening. However, no-one is really going to choose any of the Mini range for practicality, and thankfully the driving experience makes up for this deficiency.

It is tricky to get the Mini to slide around when driving enthusiastically, as it is so fantastically well glued to the road. Part of this is due to a slightly firm suspension setup, which is not aided by the large wheels that seem to come with most Minis. A 16-inch alloy is large for a car this small, and a smaller option would help smooth the ride out.

The Clubman and the hatch are equally good to drive, with the steering fantastically responsive in all three of the models. The Convertible only loses out because of the less rigid setup that removing the roof from a car necessitates. It rattles when faced with potholes and imperfect road surfaces so is more suited to posing than enthusiastic driving.

One more addition as a result of the facelift is the smart phone docking station that allows you to listen to digital radio through the car. However, at the moment it only works with Apple's iPhone, and it spent most of the time during testing either searching for a station or proclaiming it wasn't available. With more development this could be a handy piece of kit, but at the moment it is not worth the extra investment.

Fifth Gear overall car ratings

STYLING

Despite approaching a decade in age, the Mini has barely changed at all over its lifetime. Arguably it has become an all too common sight on the UK's roads to sell on the basis of its looks . The update has done little to change this.

HANDLING

Probably not the fastest hot hatch in terms of overall speed - but the fluent, adjustable chassis means it's definitely one of the most fun. Despite the torque steer evident on the more powerful models, it's impossible to drive down a winding road without a grin on your face.

COMFORT

The firm ride is likely to create rough progress over some of Britain's pockmarked roads, but the driving position is vastly improved over that of the old car. Go for smaller wheels to soften the ride.

QUALITY & RELIABILITY

Well constructed and well designed - although some of the cabin plastics feel a bit cheap considering the serious pricetags attached to range-toppers. The interior is beginning to look its age.

PERFORMANCE

The One will need to be worked hard to create rapid progress, but the Cooper is fast and the Cooper S's turbocharged engine gives it a serious turn of speed. The diesel is set up to drive like a petrol and revs happily, but is not keen to pull away in too high a gear.

ROOMINESS

Comfortable for two front-seat occupants, but the rear seat isn't really up to anyone larger than small kids. The boot is small compared to more conventional superminis, and even the Clubman isn't what you'd call practical.

STEREO / SAT NAV

The standard audio system works well, although it struggles a bit to make itself heard over wind-noise at motorway cruising speeds. Optional satnav is expensive, and the digital radio that connects through your smart phone is not good enough to justify the expense.

RUNNING COSTS

Excellent fuel economy and strong resale values mean the Mini should be impressively easy on the wallet.

VALUE FOR MONEY

The facelift brings another price rise, which is offset by an increase in standard equipment, although you're still going to need to pay a premium for the Mini over more mainstream options.

ENVIRONMENT

The Mini is one of the cleanest cars in its segment, with the impressive diesel engine heading below 100g/km. The petrols are all competitive but not class leading, and will make up the bulk of sales hence the less than perfect score

This review has been tagged with: Mini | Mini Mini | Mini Hatchback

There are 36 variants of the Hatchback

Hatchback variants Price (£) Fuel type Engine
size (cc)
CO2 emission
(g/km)
First 3dr £11,810 1598 127
One 3dr £13,400 1598 127
One 5dr £14,430 1598 129
One D 3dr £14,480 1598 99
One Auto 3dr £14,615 1598 150
Cooper 3dr £14,840 1598 127
One D 5dr £15,470 1598 103
One Auto 5dr £15,680 1598 152
Cooper 5dr £15,770 1598 129
One 2dr £15,805 1598 133
Cooper Auto 3dr £16,055 1598 150
Cooper D 3dr £16,120 1598 99
One Auto 2dr £16,940 1598 154
Cooper Auto 5dr £17,020 1598 152
Cooper D 5dr £17,120 1598 103
Cooper 2dr £17,235 1598 133
Cooper D Auto 3dr £17,320 1598 135
Cooper S 3dr £18,075 1598 136
Cooper D 2dr £18,310 1598 105
Cooper D Auto 5dr £18,320 1598 138
Cooper Auto 2dr £18,370 1598 154
Cooper SD 3dr £18,810 1995 114
Cooper S 5dr £19,055 1598 137
Cooper S Auto 3dr £19,235 1598 149
Cooper D Auto 2dr £19,510 1598 140
Cooper SD 5dr £19,790 1995 115
Cooper SD Auto 3dr £20,070 1995 139
Cooper S Auto 5dr £20,215 1598 150
Cooper S 2dr £20,395 1598 139
Cooper SD Auto 5dr £21,065 1995 141
Cooper SD 2dr £21,130 1995 118
Cooper S Auto 2dr £21,590 1598 153
Cooper SD Auto 2dr £22,405 1995 143
Clubman 5dr £23,305 1598 167
3dr £23,390 1598 165
Convertible 2dr £24,780 1598 169
 

Average

5

User reviews (7)

Leave a review

rae540048
5

I have owned three new mini cooper s from new since they came out in 2002 they have all been great to drive the latest is the best you wont regret it if you buy one it also has 5 years waranty if you pay £140 when new and that is transferable when you sell it free service is also included I have traded mine in at a mini garage and got a great price for my old car they just seem to get better all the time plus the fact you know everybody wants one

Report as inappropriate
Jefferson1
5

Recently traded in my Cooper D for an S. Wow ! What a difference. A totally superb car. Every journey a thrill. Looks fantastic. Best car I've ever driven. So much power. Even the ride quality's great despite 17 in wheels. Magnificent.

Report as inappropriate
m s hughes
5

great show

Report as inappropriate
Jon
5

I have had a Mini for several months and love it. Great Car. You don't buy a Mini for the space in the back! Plus the satnav is awesome and iphone links in so well! May be expensive but the car holds it value much better than its rivals so in the long run is more economical! Also if it wasn't styled like a Mini then it wouldn't be a Mini!

Report as inappropriate
Derrick
5

I've owned 2010 Mini Cooper S for several months now and been loving it ever since I drove it off the dealership. Great performance, and truly go-kart like feel to it. I did some mod to the mini so it's pulling 280 bhp and I can't wipe the grin off my face! With the sport mode on, it wants to pull on every gear! Only regret I have is that I should've bought JCW edition instead of regular MCS....but for what it's worth, I look forward to get up in the morning and go for a drive.

Report as inappropriate
daboy
5

The reviewer was, well a reviewer! Ask a real owner and then take the plunge. I've owned mine for 12 months and never fail to get out at the end of a trip (no matter how small) with a smile on my face. As for handling - it does handle fantastically, but your not driving it properly if you can't get it to hop through the corners! ;) Rules the Bends and Bends the Rules!

Report as inappropriate
thomas wicksteed
4

Have given 4 stars as per your review as I have not driven one of the BMW Minis. However it has to be said that Clarkson is spot on (I can't believe I am saying this) in raising the problems faced when a pastiche of an earlier design itself needs radical updating. Evidently BMW are aware of the need for more adequate interior space hence the Clubman and Countryman models. However they are hogtied by the "retro" image and these vehicles are getting progressively odder in appearance. The facias are getting ever stranger and one suspects the next stage will be for the central instrument panel to be larger than the steering wheel! BMW cannot rely on committed Mini fans for ever. There is formidable competition out there. I have just bought one.

Report as inappropriate

Join Channel 5

Creating an account is free, will only take a few moments and will allow you to enjoy the full benefits of 5FWD and Channel 5:

  • Create lists of your most wanted and owned products
  • Leave article comments without having to re-enter your login details
  • Get updated with all the latest gadget and car news

Leave a comment

Please note that we will not expose your email, but we might use it to email you back. Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.
* mandatory field

* Enter your rating:

Quick car search

Find a car review

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
See all