Channel 5 Register | Sign in |
 
 

Mini CountrymanSeptember 2010

Average.

It looks like a stretched Mini, but it is actually on a completely different platform. Part Golf-competitor, part crossover SUV, it is Mini's equivalent to the Nissan Qashqai.

Our rating:

3

User rating:

3_5
Mini Countryman
 
 

Fifth Gear Mini Countryman review

 
 
1. Mini image
2. Wacky interior
3. Quality feel

WE DON'T LIKE

1. Original Mini styling has been stretched to breaking-point
2. Not nearly as much fun to drive as the hatchback
3. Looks and feels a bit contrived
 
 

There are two targets for the Countryman: to provide a car that Mini owners with growing families can move into, and more generally, take on the whole lower medium segment for Focus-sized cars. There is no question that the Countryman will appeal to lapsed Mini owners - the main reason Mini hatchback owners left the brand was that the car was too small for their growing families. But life gets more tricky for buyers previously impervious to the Mini's charms. When you drive the Mini hatchback for the first time, you immediately get it - it might not be the right car for you, but you understand exactly what the Mini is about: style and fun. When you drive the Countryman, you are more likely to be scratching your head. It does offer Golf-rivalling space, but only by stretching the basic Mini shape in all sorts of unlikely ways (notice how the window of the rear door looks longer than the window of the front door). It does not have the same fun-to-drive feel as the hatchback (or even a Focus for that matter), always feeling a bit too tall for hammering down country lanes. The off-road ability of the All4 version is also limited - certainly well behind a Skoda Yeti. What it does have is the image of a Mini, which counts for a lot: the Mini brand is something a lot of people want to be associated with.

It is not that the Countryman is a bad car - it is objectively reasonable-to-good in most departments, and it is certainly different. However, it will succeed or fail on its image. It has got off to a strong start, but only time will tell of it becomes an enduring style icon like the Mini hatchback, or if it burns itself out after a few years like the modern incarnation of the VW Beetle.

Fifth Gear overall car ratings

STYLING

Clearly a Mini, its stretched-in-all-directions look is not a total success. The front-end is a bit gawky and the overall shape lacks the cohesion of the hatchback.

HANDLING

The ultra-sharp steering seems out of character with the tall body that dulls handling responses. The steering responds instantly, but then you have to wait for the body to settle.

COMFORT

The ride is firm and well-damped and the front seats are comfortable. The rear ones have plenty of space, but are flat and a bit thin.

QUALITY & RELIABILITY

It's made by BMW, so it's a quality item. However, there were a few interior zizzes on the early test cars over rough roads.

PERFORMANCE

Modern Mini engines mean decent performance - but the Countryman is bigger, and therefore a bit slower than the hatchback. The Cooper S is no hot hatch.

ROOMINESS

Basically the same as a conventional lower-medium hatchback, although the extra height gives unusually good headroom.

STEREO / SAT NAV

A decent standard system. The expensive optional sat nav works fine once you have found the joystick controller (it is in front of the handbrake).

RUNNING COSTS

Economical engines, the option of fixed price servicing, and strong residual values make the Countryman better than average.

VALUE FOR MONEY

It's about what you expect, being about the same price as a Golf of similar power.

ENVIRONMENT

Most diesel engines get below 120g/km of CO2 while petrol engines are mostly around 140 g/km. That is good, but there is no super-frugal model in the range.

This review has been tagged with: Mini | Mini Countryman

 

Average

3_5

User reviews (8)

Leave a review

lightfoot1
3

Liked the quality feel and the chunky look. Found the interior claustrophobic and the driver legroom limited. Seat squabs felt too flat and lacking in support for thighs. More fashion than function with not enough ground clearance for rough tracks. More towny than country we thought. We are going for a Yeti. Disappointed as it looked good in the brochures and the running costs should be low.

Report as inappropriate
Galen10
5

I think the original review is way off the mark. I test drove the basic Countryman One and the Cooper D and found them both great to drive, so can't understand why the review is so negative; most other reviews seem to disagree with your view too. It is definitely a car that looks better in the metal than on paper, and is at least as roomy and pratical in terms of internal space as my current Golf. All in all, I was so impressed that I've placed an order for a Cooper D, rather than replace my Mk. V Golf with a Mk. VI; the Countryman is much more fun to drive, will depreciate less, cost less to buy and less to run than the equivalent Golf. Even if I was needed a 4 wheel drive (which I don't, particularly not for an extra £1000!), I'd still chose a Countryman over a Skoda Yeti or a Nissan Juke anyday... both are ugly as sin!

Report as inappropriate
mike
4

All the so called experts complained about the lack of room in the normal BMW mini ,now they say the new ones too big, what does it tell you about the motoring press and the public at large. You can only please some of the people some of the time !

Report as inappropriate
Anonymous
2

dont like this one theyve totally spoilt the looks poor dash as well

Report as inappropriate
Bennyboy27
3

Mini/BMW have not gone by the word mini. They have made a stylish 4-door car which is made harder to park.Mini's were made for quick sharp cars which you could easily park, now thats why you have a BMW to carry familys. Mini's were made for family of 3 or maybe squeeze in 4. Mini's never used to have a middle back seat but Why cant they just stick to the stylish 2-door car.

Report as inappropriate
paul.hitchcock
3

Unfair to rate a vehicle I have never travelled in let alone driven but this strange looking creation validates everything J. Clarkson has said about the problems faced by retro brands when they have to update. (How strange to find myself agreeing with Mr. Clarkson!) The fascia looks absurd rather than practical as well. I remember the joys and pitfalls of owning a "real" Mini very well. Pin sharp steering, useless brakes; always go out with a spare water pump bypass hose in case it has to be replaced en route etc. etc. By alll means create an updated and improved vehicle with a similar character using the same name badge but the car actually produced was more "tubby" than "mini". B.M.W. will have real problems in designing a plausible successor and they will need to do this. Hard core enthusiasts are not enough top keep any manufacturer in business; their products have to have wider appeal.

Report as inappropriate
Ron Stamp
5

Mini has been the least depreciating car on the market, it is a great car but the countryman is not a mini replacement, it is a totally new car with a Mini badge. I must say that BMW have got it right, just look at some of the boring cars on the market, probably out there to suit some of the boring people. Thats a fact

Report as inappropriate
Paul Hitchcock
3

Parked near to two black painted examples today. It struck me that the quality of the paintwork was noticeably poorer than with the "normal" Mini, whilst the alloys, both "plain" and black painted, had a rather cheap air about them. The styling still strikes me as having a home made air about it. Perhaps it is aimed at the transantic market.

Report as inappropriate

Join Channel 5

Creating an account is free, will only take a few moments and will allow you to enjoy the full benefits of 5FWD and Channel 5:

  • Create lists of your most wanted and owned products
  • Leave article comments without having to re-enter your login details
  • Get updated with all the latest gadget and car news

Leave a comment

Please note that we will not expose your email, but we might use it to email you back. Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.
* mandatory field

* Enter your rating:

Quick car search

Find a car review

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
See all