Channel 5 Register | Sign in |
 
 

BMW X1October 2009

Recommended.

A very capable addition to the small SUV market from BMW that should appeal to premium buyers looking to downsize.

Our rating:

4

User rating:

4_5
BMW X1
 
 

Fifth Gear BMW X1 review

 
 
1. Looks are a good balance of car and SUV
2. Option of two-wheel drive to bring cost and CO2 down
3. Car-like handling

WE DON'T LIKE

1. Ill-defined difference between the X1 and X3
2. Firm ride when fitted with run-flat tyres
3. Not cheap to buy - and even more expensive when you start adding options
 
 

BMW has recognised the unpopularity of SUVs in the current climate of environmental awareness and has followed the trend for downsizing by adding a smaller model to its X range, the X1.

From most angles, the X1 looks like any other X model, with its rugged front and rear bumpers, muscular exterior and bulging side skirts. But there are also distinctly car-like features: for example, the elongated bonnet and hatchback-style tailgate are closer to that of a 1-Series than an X3.

Inside, the car-like theme continues with a beautifully finished dashboard and a centre console that has been angled subtly towards the driver's seat for a more cockpit-like feel. The driving position itself, although 8cm lower than the X3, is still higher than a conventional car, giving the X1 driver a more elevated viewpoint.

On the road, the X1 benefits from having characteristics from both cars and SUVs. BMW has kept body roll sufficiently in check to allow it to be capable of a lively back-road sprint and, when equipped with four-wheel drive, there's a good deal of grip too. The ride feels sophisticated and it proves itself to be very comfortable when called upon to travel long distances.

The X1 is the first X model to be available in both two-wheel drive (sDrive) and 4WD (xDrive). In 2WD guise, power is sent to the rear wheels, so there's even an element of the focused, rear-wheel-drive nature you expect from other models in the BMW range.

Leave the tarmac though, (which BMW admits few owners are likely to do) and the X1 turns into very capable off-roader. It even holds its own over rugged terrain in 2WD form.

The diesel-only line-up of three engines comprises 18d, 20d and 23d units generating 143, 170 and 200bhp, respectively. The pick of the bunch is the excellent 20d, which, while punchy, also serves up impressive CO2 emissions and fuel economy - especially in rear-wheel-drive form.

So the X1 is yet another accomplished SUV from BMW that will slot into the small SUV market above the VW Tiguan and Ford Kuga. Where its arrival will leave the less well-received X3 is anyone's guess.

Fifth Gear overall car ratings

STYLING

The X1 is a decent-looking SUV with rugged styling coupled with car-like features, such as the long bonnet and hatchback rear. Inside, the interior is classic and unfussy - befitting of this type of car.

HANDLING

The X1 is very capable off and on the road. When pushing on, it feels composed and controlled in tight bends: there's also excellent stability and a decent level of grip, especially when fitted with four-wheel drive. In two-wheel-drive the X1 feels less poised, but it's still fun to drive.

COMFORT

The X1 possesses very large seats for a relatively small car. They're made all the more comfortable thanks to a suspension set-up that can cope with most bumps and potholes effortlessly - although some models are fitted with run-flat tyres that can make the ride a little on the firm side. The cabin is beautifully finished with plenty of light and excellent visibility, with wind and road noise kept to a minimum and any engine growl is only really audible under heavy acceleration.

QUALITY & RELIABILITY

Its hard to fault the X1 for quality. The interior has all the soft-touch materials and excellent build quality we've come to expect from BMW over the years. We expect reliability to be extremely good too.

PERFORMANCE

The X1's engine range consists of three diesel engines, with the 18d, 20d, 23d generating 140bhp, 173bhp and 198bhp, respectively. The 23d will get the X1 from standstill to 62mph in 7.3 seconds while even the lesser-powered 18d will manage the same in less than 10 seconds with two-wheel drive.

ROOMINESS

BMW is claiming X3 levels of rear space in the X1 and we can't disagree. There's plenty of room for two adults in the rear - the middle seat will fit a third at a squeeze - and there is ample storage throughout the cabin. Bootspace is good, at 420 litres (around 60 litres less than the X3) but with the seats folded completely flat it expands to over 1,350 litres, which is comparable to a 3-Series Touring.

STEREO / SAT NAV

As you'd expect from a BMW, the X1 is fitted with a very good six-speaker stereo and the option of integrated or aftermarket sat nav, both of which are intuitive with clear and easy-to-understand graphics.

RUNNING COSTS

For an SUV the X1 is suprisingly frugal. There are only diesel engines on offer so all offer decent fuel economy ranging from 44.8mpg up to 53.4mpg. Likewise the 2WD sDrive18d offers CO2 emissions of just 136g/km costing just £120 per year in road tax. Its a BMW so servicing costs will be higher than a non-premium brand but insurance costs should be reasonable.

VALUE FOR MONEY

The X1 is a premium offering in the SUV market, so it is priced higher than some of its more mainstream competitors - and that's before you start ticking the boxes on a long options list, which can mean a moderately spec'ed car can easily start to cost around £27-28K.

ENVIRONMENT

For a medium-sized SUV, the X1 is a good performer, environmentally speaking. With the option of 2WD for the first time in an X car, BMW has been able to reduce CO2 emissions. Equipped with the 18d engine and 2WD, CO2 emissions are below 140g/km. All X1s have also been kitted out with the latest BMW EfficientDynamics technology.

This review has been tagged with: BMW | BMW X1

 

Average

4_5

User reviews (20)

Leave a review

Bob
5

The X1 is great because most people who buy a big car don't really need 4WD. It looks really boring, though.

Report as inappropriate
Barkie
5

Test drove the 20d xDrive as few weeks ago, and liked it enough to order as a company car. In fact I ordered the 18d sDrive as it is cheap on BIK and economy looks superb. Fits 3 kids in the back (2 in boosters) nicely. Certainly looking forward to having this sitting on the driveway gleaming!

Report as inappropriate
Nuno
5

The specifications speek for himself. It beats most of the competitors. Performance, height, consuption, brakes, etc...

Report as inappropriate
clive williams
5

I test drove a 4wd auto with conventional tyres and the ride was fine.I ordered mine with run-flats BUT on standard size tyres and the ride is still fine. The problem is probably not the run-flats but the skinny section tyres that accompany fancy alloys. I am very happy with the rest of the car, it is more comfortable than by previous 3 series estate and just as quiet.

Report as inappropriate
Emma Smith
5

The test drive at Peterborough dealership was excellent. The salesman ( Karl) showed brilliant communication skills in understanding our requirements and was highly skilled in demostrating the buy points on the X1. The overall test drive we found was uncomplecated and we managed to discover that this was the car for us from the first test drive! The ride was comfortable and quiet adding to the fact that the vehicle is very ecomonical with savings to both Road Tax and fuel with the same performance and style that we have come to expect from the German manufacturer. We went in to look at the X3 and discovered a vehicle that exceeds our requirements from a family car. We liked it so much we purchased It!

Report as inappropriate

This review has been removed.

Anonymous
4

Collected a 2.0d Xdrive on the 1st March. I emailed a petrol-head mate the following: 'With all this tech now, the handover was almost 2 hours! Set up this and that and then try it all out. Of course I needed to sign a doc saying the sales guy had explained everything to me.................well to be honest I couldn't take much more in. There's a facility known as BMW connected drive whereby an operator pings addresses and phone numbers to your car and you can then instruct the nav to take you there etc. I can also use my pc to send the car stuff. Useful? I'll let you know! Otherwise, really comfortable sport seats with bolsters which are infinitely adjustable. Sit low by comparison to Kuga. Very nice ride and turn in. You sit 'in' the seats, not 'on' them. Panoramic roof opens which is a treat. Not sure about the colour! Chose graphite blue, came out a bit lighter than I had expected. Difficult to tell what the whole car will look like when you chose from a panel 8 inches square on order! Beige leather interior lifts it though. Sound system miles better than the Nissan. IPod connection good with menu on car screen. Garage door opener integrated into rear view mirror. Not much interior stowage space. It's really a pumped up 3 series estate (had looked at a 330d SE but as it is due to be replaced 2011 decided not to proceed). Car mag reviews a little harsh on the interior. Granted the basic model feels very low rent'.

Report as inappropriate

This review has been removed.

Jason
5

Just ordered X1 23d x drive for my wife. Car looks great, and the car we test drove solid. Decided to leave out the 18" Alloys, as only avalible with runflats ( Hate them ) I wish BMW would stop putting runflats on all there nice alloys, just spoils the ride and massive cost to replace ! My BMW 530d M Sport with 19" alloys does not have runflats, Come on !

Report as inappropriate
ARNE MADSEN
5

The BMW x1 Automatic is by far the best car I have driven, the result - I ordered mine after the testdrive. I like the way it handles - on dry as well as snow & ice. The handling is close to perfect and I'm just looking for an excuse to go out and fire it up.

Report as inappropriate
Northern Lights
5

The X1 is not a remarkable car, but It is a really good one! Having said that I´d like to point out what I appreciate about it: In snowy Scandinavia this car will get you where you want to and in comfort It takes at least 3 people with luggage. The BMW X1 tackles icy and slippery roads with ease. The fuel consumption is remarkably low at high speeds compared to city/mixed driving. The heater/ac works very well. All dials and buttons on the dash are within easy reach and easy to understand. No manual required. If rush-hour traffic is experienced, the automatic transmission conquers this. The cruise control takes you through highways in comfort. What about the handling? The X1 feels like driving a Jet aircraft as opposed to a kite. You feel in so touch with the road and you experience full control at all speeds. With run flat tires you will appreciate bumpy roads and speed obstacles in the roads. The JAGUAR XF 3.0 D S PREMIUM has a superior engine, cruise control and looks vs the X1. The Sat Nav and steering wheel leaves a lot to be desired! I´d rather have the X1 for my daily life. What is best in Britain is not necessarily best in the Alps or in Scandinavia. Car taxation plays a role. Summary: Here in Norway I´d rather have the "Beemer X1" than the Audi A4 Allroad Quattro or Jag XF 3.0 D due to it´s completeness. Yes the BMW X1 2.0 diesel really is loud when cold. Perhaps it is old, I dunno. Happy motoring!

Report as inappropriate
Anonymous
3

Left my first review in March having had the car a week (a 2.0d xdrive). Now, having lived with the vehicle for 9 months and 10k miles all I can say is that I wish I had gone for the 2.3. The 2 litre lacks any go, and is noisy when pressed. I also find the steering heavy in town driving especially negotiating small streets. Recently test drove a 1 series 123d coupe and the rack was quick and light by comparison. Tempted to chop the X1 in but the p/ex was derisory. The X1 is an accomplished car in general though, but doesn't light any fires.

Report as inappropriate
Dr Amir
5

I just bought a X1 23d with basically everything well ok I do not have leather seating, electrial movable seats and heated steering wheel. Else I have everything in it. Also remember getting sport chassi with performance controll since this really puts the car to another comforting level.

Report as inappropriate
M.B
4

I'm comparing the X1 18i, with BMW 320i, and Audi A4 any suggestions which is the best?

Report as inappropriate
lochlassie
3

Bought my x1 2l sdrive in Feb this year and find it awful to handle in single track or any form of uneven road. I have been told its because of the wide low profile run flat tyres. I am dreading the snow! On a plus - Fuel economy is wonderful. Sound system: speakers bang if turned up too loud, cd skips back and forth. I have taken it back to the dealership to have this checked out but was made out to be a liar. It still does it. Personally I would say it is the worst car I have driven. I currently have it for sale, anyone?

Report as inappropriate
chris holland
5

anyone know where to get a good lease deal on an X1 - 18d or 20d sDrive? thanks, Chris

Report as inappropriate
mark
5

Iv had my 20s drive for about 4 months and have e done 7k and the more I drive it the more I love I, my old car was a Octavia vrs cr and find the bm only a small compromise on handling and speed. It feels soft but soon stiffens up into the corners and as for speed you need to floor it, then it fly’s. As a company car its low on co2 and returns high 40’s so cannot ask for more. Did try the ford and VW ford to slow you needed to work it and then it was to soft into the corners and as for the VW 170 only good for the school run what happened to all the power as it’s the same engine as the vrs !

Report as inappropriate
marzelina ahmad marzuki
4

Beautiful and nice car, I wish my husband buy me one BMW car as promised.

Report as inappropriate
Feras
4

Test drove my cousin's X1 and I really like it. The room inside isn't it's strongest suit & the steering is quite heavy. It handles like a car and quite frankly its so compact it does look like one. Feels like an SUV though when you go inside. Make sure to test drive it before you buy one.

Report as inappropriate
Ian
1

What a lemon! Having had my Fabia vRS stoved in by a careless truck driver, my mood lifted when told by insurers the replacement would be a BMW - like a child promised a fancy toy after an unpleasant trip to the dentist. Never having seen an X1 I didn't give much of a glance to the 'Kia Rio' slowing down as it approached my house. Then I saw the familiar kidney grille of a BMW. No matter, I thought, okay it looks hideous, but it will be fantastic to drive. All BMWs are designed for driving pleasure and this one was festooned with 'M Sport' logos. How wrong I was. I know my Fabia is a hot hatch, but even so, the BMW engine is bigger, has more power and is a far more modern design. Yet the acceleration has the modesty of a honey badger trying to outrun a cheetah. Rev range is nowhere near as flexible as the Audi unit in my Fabia, which will pull happily from 30 in third, fourth or fifth. The X1, on the other hand, is as inflexible as a Tory PM at an EU summit. Unless you're in exactly ther right gear for the road speed, the whole thing wheezes and shudders. There's far too much general vibration too, especially through the gear knob. You may be thinking, okay it's not fast but it's a quality SUV. Wrong again. Some of the dashboard plastics would grace an old Kia or Hyundai from the last millenium. The driving pedals are uncomfortably offset, the heating controls are set too low, the seatbelt point is jammed between the handbrake and the front seat, and you can't see out of the back. Yes, you can get 50 miles to the gallon - but what's the point. The latest Kia and Hyundais are just as spacious, better to look at, and just as economical. Save yourself £10k. I for one, have been put off BMW.

Report as inappropriate

Join Channel 5

Creating an account is free, will only take a few moments and will allow you to enjoy the full benefits of 5FWD and Channel 5:

  • Create lists of your most wanted and owned products
  • Leave article comments without having to re-enter your login details
  • Get updated with all the latest gadget and car news

Leave a comment

Please note that we will not expose your email, but we might use it to email you back. Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.
* mandatory field

* Enter your rating:

Quick car search

Find a car review

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
See all