Channel 5 Register | Sign in |
 
 

Porsche 911January 2011

Highly recommended.

Porsche's quintessential rear-engined sportscar is better to drive than ever.

Our rating:

5

User rating:

5
Porsche 911
 
 

Fifth Gear Porsche 911 review

 
 
1. Brilliant handling
2. Stunning performance
3. Reasonably practical for this sort of car, too

WE DON'T LIKE

1. Expensive options
2. Confusing range - too many variants
3. All cost a small fortune to run, with more powerful versions costing a large fortune
 
 

The Porsche 911 remains one of the great automotive anachronisms: a sportscar with its engine in the wrong place. Yet over the decades, and throughout successive generations, engineers have managed to tame the inherent instability brought on by the rear-mounted engine, creating one of the greatest driver's cars on the market.

Time has almost been called on the current generation, but its historical imprint leaves behind some of the finest cars ever to bear the 911 badge. While there is a bewildering range to flick through, the 997 delivers an almost peerless sports car experience in all its incarnations.

Financially speaking, Porsche 911 ownership begins with the Carrera range. Even at the base of the line-up the 3.6-litre flat-six engine endows the entry-level two-wheel-drive model with addictive performance (further embellished by the beefed up Carrera S) but the pick of the bunch is the recently added GTS.

As the most powerful Carrera, the GTS gets an upgraded version of the bigger 3.8-litre engine with the wider body and track usually found on the four-wheel-drive versions. The car uses the fatter footprint to great effect, combining towering grip with glorious, fluidic steering and a taut, exploitable sense of control.

Beyond the GTS lineup the 911 gets really expensive and, incredibly, even better. The GT3 has been sharpened into a hunkered-down hot rod; harder, beefier and faster than anything beneath it. But even this brand of brilliance is shaded by the GT2, which in stripped-out road-going race-car RS form is powered by a twin-turbocharged 611bhp 3.6-litre sledgehammer.

Other than the GT2, Porsche saves forced induction for the iconic Turbo, which, unlike its spartan sibling, is arguably the 911 at its most opulent. It's a tooled-up, hyper fast fist in a velvet glove, intended to suit the sensibilities and wallets of the very wealthy.

Finally there is the GT3 RS 4.0, a blistering, limited-edition final farewell to the 997 which combines a retuned suspension setup with the biggest engine to ever feature in a 911 - a race-derived 493bhp 4.0-litre flat-six.

That car will likely only ever be seen in the affluent hands of serious Porsche enthusiasts, but the 911 range's sheer magnitude ensures there are almost as many thrills to be had for half its six-figure price tag. Critically, all blend reliability and comparative practicality with the consummate performance car of the last half decade.

Fifth Gear overall car ratings

STYLING

Not the most original piece of design - it's hard to tell this 911 from the previous generation at first glance. But handsome, well detailed and, let's face it, essential.

HANDLING

A rear-mounted engine should be a recipe for dynamic catastrophe, yet Porsche has made the 911 handle brilliantly across the range. The GT3 and GT2 offer a significant step up in ability, but the RS versions can stake a serious claim as the best drivers' cars ever made.

COMFORT

The ride is firm and can occasionally get joggly over rougher surfaces, but high-speed cruising manners are exemplary and the driving position is brilliant no matter which model you opt for.

QUALITY & RELIABILITY

The 911 has earned its reputation for reliability over five decades of gradual improvement, and the 997 feels about as solidly constructed as it's possible for sports car to get. That said, the interior design is starting to look its age.

PERFORMANCE

Even the most basic version is satisfyingly quick, but the gutsy GTS is the Carrera to buy. The GT3 and GT2 RS variants are amongst the fastest cars on the planet.

ROOMINESS

Front seat occupants enjoy reasonable space, but the rear seats are barely up to moving small children short distances, and the small front boot is awkward to access. Expect the more extreme versions to come with a space-eating roll cage.

STEREO / SAT NAV

The audio system delivers clean, crisp sound to both front seat occupants. Optional satnav system works well.

RUNNING COSTS

You'll need a very healthy bank account to even contemplate putting a 911 on the driveway but healthy residual values mean it costs considerably less to own than supercar rivals.

VALUE FOR MONEY

Basic versions have reasonable equipment, but the options list is deep and expensive. It's alarmingly easy to watch the price spiral out of control.

ENVIRONMENT

The 2011 range was the first 911 to get down to 225 g/km of CO2, so there will be considerable road tax benefits. In absolute terms the 911 is poor, but it is still better than any other supercar.

This review has been tagged with: Porsche | porsche 911

There are 34 variants of the 911

911 variants Price (£) Fuel type Engine
size (cc)
CO2 emission
(g/km)
Carrera 3.4 3dr £71,449 3436 212
Carrera 4 3.6 3dr £71,883 3614 237
Carrera 3.4 PDK 3dr £73,836 3436 194
Carrera 4 3.6 PDK 3dr £74,271 3614 237
Targa 4 3dr £77,629 3614 237
GTS 3dr £78,370 3800 242
Carrera 4 3.6 Cabriolet 2dr £79,572 3614 242
Carrera Cabriolet 2dr £79,947 3436 217
Targa 4 PDK 3dr £80,017 3614 242
Carrera 4S 3.8 3dr £80,785 3800 247
GTS PDK 3dr £80,895 3800 240
Carrera S 3.8 3dr £81,242 3800 224
Carrera 4 3.6 PDK Cabriolet 2dr £81,960 3614 242
Carrera PDK Cabriolet 2dr £82,334 3436 198
Carrera 4 GTS Coupe 3dr £83,145 3800 247
Carrera 4S 3.8 PDK 3dr £83,173 3800 247
Carrera S 3.8 PDK 3dr £83,629 3800 205
GTS Cabriolet 2dr £85,249 3800 242
Carrera 4 GTS PDK Coupe 3dr £85,670 3800 247
Targa 4S 3dr £86,532 3800 247
GTS PDK Cabriolet 2dr £87,774 3800 242
Carrera 4S 3.8 Cabriolet 2dr £88,474 3800 251
Targa 4S PDK 3dr £88,920 3800 251
Carrera S Cabriolet 2dr £89,740 3800 229
Carrera 4 GTS Cabriolet 2dr £90,024 3800 251
Carrera 4S 3.8 PDK Cabriolet 2dr £90,862 3800 251
Carrera S PDK Cabriolet 2dr £92,127 3800 210
Carrera 4 GTS PDK Cabriolet 2dr £92,549 3800 251
Turbo 3dr £110,232 3800 272
Turbo PDK 3dr £112,894 3800 268
Turbo Cabriolet 2dr £118,015 3800 275
Turbo PDK Cabriolet 2dr £120,677 3800 270
Turbo S 3dr £125,865 3800 268
Turbo S Cabriolet 2dr £133,553 3800 270
 

Average

5

User reviews (7)

Leave a review

This review is awaiting moderation.

ziroko
5

porsche is porsche.

Report as inappropriate
Metallic-Legend
5

porsche kicks ass

Report as inappropriate
GamerGeek97
5

i own 1 it rocks

Report as inappropriate
publandlord1
5

just bought a 2002 turbo that was some oxygen thiefs play thing! never driven any car thats as bonkers as this. hope ive still got my license for christmas. in fact customers in my pub have a sweepstake going on how long it will be before its taken from me! i might shock them and hang on to it, they have only had the new underpants please ride which they say they deserve as they have bought it indirectly, by buying my beer. fair comment but away from them what a great peice of kit at even legal limits.

Report as inappropriate
Nick
4

All perfect except for the running costs - like a beautiful girl with a wart on her nose

Report as inappropriate
Grah
5

Unusual looks, but utterly beautiful to drive - steering sharp and precise, body well controlled when manoeuvring, turbine-like power delivery even on my base model engine - try before you die!

Report as inappropriate

Join Channel 5

Creating an account is free, will only take a few moments and will allow you to enjoy the full benefits of 5FWD and Channel 5:

  • Create lists of your most wanted and owned products
  • Leave article comments without having to re-enter your login details
  • Get updated with all the latest gadget and car news

Leave a comment

Please note that we will not expose your email, but we might use it to email you back. Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.
* mandatory field

* Enter your rating:

Quick car search

Find a car review

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
See all