Channel 5 Register | Sign in |
 
 

Volkswagen SharanJuly 2010

Recommended.

A massive and practical people carrier that offers a decent range of optional toys, but the looks and drive are anything but exciting.

Our rating:

4

User rating:

5
Volkswagen Sharan
 
 

Fifth Gear Volkswagen Sharan review

 
 
1. Massive boot space
2. Seats are easily folded completely flat
3. Doesn't feel as big to drive as it is

WE DON'T LIKE

1. Bland looks
2. Seats are not as easy to put back up as they are to fold down
3. Gutless and thirsty small petrol engine
 
 

After 15 years loyal service, with just two facial refreshes to keep it from showing its age, Volkswagen has replaced its highly popular people carrier - the Sharan.

While the old car achieved was instantly recognisable because it formed the basis of the Seat Alhambra and the first generation Ford Galaxy, the new one is immediately familiar because it adopts the 'family' nose that is slowly spreading across the Volkswagen range. Inevitably this means the Sharan bears a strong resemblance the Golf and the Polo, but it also makes the people carrier depressingly bland.

But as looks are not top of the list of requirements for MPV buyers, it is inside that sees the most innovations and improvements over what was its worthy predecessor. UK cars come with seven seats as standard, most of which can be folded and slid to accommodate passengers and luggage as required.

The neatest trick is how all five of the rear seats fold flat, creating a cavernous 2,297 litre luggage carrying area. The third row - which is by no means designed just for smaller passengers, it will take two adults, even if only on short to medium journeys - is easily flipped down by tugging on a single handle. The second row folds away just as swiftly, and panels on the back of the rear seats can be flipped over to cover up the crevices that appear.

So far everything can be done one-handed, but the refolding is a little trickier. Not only does it require a little more effort, but the third row can't be put back in place while reaching in through just one door. It has to be pulled back into place from the back door and then secured from the side.

The Sharan's obliging nature is enhanced by the electric gadgets on offer. Both the sliding passenger doors and the bootlid can be electrically opened and closed - all three have an automatic cutoff to prevent stray limbs or fingers getting caught - and there is also a new and improved auto parking system.

Volkswagens have so far offered a park assist that guides the car through a parallel park, but the Sharan is the first that claims to be able to park into a space that is at right angles to the road. It proved to have a few glitches on test though, first cutting a corner and mounting a kerb, and then failing to identify a large space without the reference point of other cars.

The engine range will include the twincharged 1.4-litre petrol that has formed the basis of smaller and zippier Volkswagens. Predictably it struggles slightly in the 1,650kg Sharan, and fuel economy is compromised as a result. The pick of the range is the 138bhp 2.0-litre diesel, which pulls the Sharan's bulk in a much more satisfying manner.

Fifth Gear overall car ratings

STYLING

This is not the Sharan's strong point, but then it is unlikely that many of the 600,000 that VW sold of the old version were bought because of its looks.

HANDLING

For a very large car - not much short of five meters in length - the Sharan handles surprisingly well. Don't expect it to provide wild amounts of fun once you have dropped the kids off at school, but it will at least feel like you are piloting a car at least a category or two smaller thanks to light steering and the parking assist option.

COMFORT

So long as you avoid the Sport option on the dynamic control button (a totally pointless feature on a car this size) the Sharan will waft along in supreme comfort. There is little body roll under normal driving conditions, yet it manages to avoid the harsh ride that often comes as a compromise in this situation.

QUALITY & RELIABILITY

Everything feels beautifully solid in the Sharan's cabin, enough to repel the inquisitive attention of younger passengers. The base model is a little basic in areas, but elements such as the steering wheel and dashboard materials are all pleasing to the touch.

PERFORMANCE

None of the engines feel particularly fast, with 0-60mph times hovering around the 10 second mark, but the diesels especially offer enough grunt to reassure you that they will be able to overtake slower vehicles when required.

ROOMINESS

This could be nothing but a five star score - the boot is massive, and all five of the rear seats fold away neatly to create a flat loading space. Legroom in the second row is excellent with the seats slid all the way back, and decent when they are moved forward to accommodate passengers in the third row.

STEREO / SAT NAV

As the UK will eventually scrap the analogue radio service, including a digital radio as standard is helpful as Sharan owners will not have to worry about the changeover. The satnav is only available as an optional extra, but the touchscreen system is easy to use and clear in instructions.

RUNNING COSTS

The admirable 138bhp 2.0-litre diesel claims an average fuel economy in excess of 50mpg, which is fantastic for a car this big, even if you only get within 10 percent of that figure. Volkswagens enjoy a good reputation for reliability, and there's no reason to think the Sharan will be bothering the local mechanics too much.

VALUE FOR MONEY

The basic model is not poorly equipped - front and rear climate control, a digital radio and electric windows all round are all standard - but you have to go right up the range to get the likes of the panoramic sunroof, alloy wheels and cruise control. The electric doors are only a cost option.

ENVIRONMENT

The diesel engines are the best for fuel economy, and emissions for both power outputs sit comfortably under the 155g/km mark, making this one of the cleanest MPVs ever. The petrols suffer with carrying such a large bulk - even the smallest emits more than 170g/km, but they are not likely to sell in great numbers, hence the favourable score.

This review has been tagged with: Volkswagen | Volkswagen Sharan

There are 18 variants of the Sharan

Sharan variants Price (£) Fuel type Engine
size (cc)
CO2 emission
(g/km)
S 1.4 TSI 5dr £24,025 1390 167
S 2.0 TDI (115ps) BlueMotion Technology 5dr £24,605 1968 146
S 1.4 TSI DSG 5dr £25,310 1390 178
S 2.0 TDI (140ps) 5dr £25,355 1968 146
SE 1.4 TSI 5dr £26,225 1390 167
S 2.0 TDI (140ps) DSG 5dr £26,590 1968 149
SE 1.4 TSI DSG 5dr £27,510 1390 178
SE 2.0 TDI (140ps) 5dr £27,555 1968 146
SE 2.0 TDI (140ps) DSG 5dr £28,790 1968 149
SE 2.0 TDI (170ps) 5dr £28,910 1968 152
SE 2.0 TDI (170ps) DSG 5dr £30,145 1968 154
SEL 2.0 TDI (140ps) 5dr £30,390 1968 146
Executive 2.0 TDI (140ps) 5dr £30,640 1968 146
SEL 2.0 TDI (140ps) DSG 5dr £31,625 1968 149
SEL 2.0 TDI (170ps) 5dr £31,745 1968 152
Executive 2.0 TDI (140ps) DSG 5dr £31,875 1968 149
SEL 2.0 TSI DSG 5dr £32,165 1968 198
SEL 2.0 TDI (170ps) DSG 5dr £32,980 1968 154
 

Average

5

User reviews (2)

Leave a review

This review has been removed.

Brian
5

I took delivery of my new Sharan in April 2011, replacing a 2008 model Sharan. I have to say I'm thoroughly impressed with it. It's a beauty to drive, and still as roomy as the old Sharan despite not being able to remove the seats any more. Performance wise my 2.0 140ps diesel it is much nippier than the old 2 litre model I had, and fuel economy is incredible. From new it has averaged 47.5mpg, and now that it is run in I regularly get 50+ on the run to/from work and up to 54 on a motorway run at a steady 73mph. On the SE model there are plenty of extras to keep me happy, and the ability to plug in my iPod and control it from my steering wheel is a Godsend. A bit expensive (but my company is paying) but still a lovely car.

Report as inappropriate

Join Channel 5

Creating an account is free, will only take a few moments and will allow you to enjoy the full benefits of 5FWD and Channel 5:

  • Create lists of your most wanted and owned products
  • Leave article comments without having to re-enter your login details
  • Get updated with all the latest gadget and car news

Leave a comment

Please note that we will not expose your email, but we might use it to email you back. Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.
* mandatory field

* Enter your rating:

Quick car search

Find a car review

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
See all