Channel 5 Register | Sign in |
 
 

Saab 9-5July 2010

Average.

Saab may have successfully untangled itself from GM's ownership, but the American giant's fingerprints are all over the new 9-5. We find out if the most important Saab in a decade can still compete.

Our rating:

3

User rating:

3
Saab 9-5
 
 

Fifth Gear Saab 9-5 review

 
 
1. Vast cabin
2. Idiosyncratic styling
3. Relatively nimble considering its proportions

WE DON'T LIKE

1. Ride is patchy around town
2. Interior trim quality is way behind premium rivals
3. Still lacks that Saab character
 
 

It's intriguing times at Saab at the moment. The company has emerged from the quagmire of GM's ownership with the fresh-faced optimism that Spyker, the Dutch sports car maker, can return the Swedish brand to the idiosyncratic roots that made it such a popular niche choice with people tired of the standard executive fare.

Saab's head of marketing equated the process to starting a car company with a blank sheet of paper. But before the 'blue sky thinking' can begin, the manufacturer has the critical job of launching its new 9-5 - the final legacy of the GM era, and the most important Saab in over a decade.

The new car has been a long time coming (its predecessor is 13 years old) and looked like it may not make it onto the road at all when the axe hung precariously over Saab's head, but it's here now, and, boy, is it big.

The 9-5 uses the long-wheelbase version of the platform that underpins the Insignia and it lends the car some serious heft. The saloon lines up against the BMW 5-Series and the Audi A6 in terms of price, but is significantly larger than both.

This gives the 9-5 an old fashioned, 'bigger is better' kind of presence. The styling is chunkier and less delicate than its competitors, and should earn some admirers prepared to forgive its slightly awkward proportions.

Inside there is the usual Saab dash, square-jawed like a boxer, and beneath it enough matt black plastic to shame a Curry's superstore. It's presentable enough and feels hardy to touch, but the 9-5 falls short of the premium quality exuded by the Germans. The 9-5 will be available in Vector SE and Aero trim levels, the latter adding extras like electrically adjustable leather seats, 19-inch wheels and sports suspension as standard.

Stabbing the new starter button on the centre console fires up either a 157bhp 2.0-litre diesel, a 216bhp 2.0-litre turbocharged petrol or the top-spec 296bhp 2.8-litre V6 lump. There's also a 1.6-litre petrol engine and twin-turbo diesel to come.

A cursory summation of the car's performance on the road might lazily conclude that the 9-5 is a big Insignia with better sound deadening, but that would be cruelly understating Saab's efforts with the car. The engineers have succeeded in disguising the saloon's substantial kerbweight with neat body control, and retuned the suspension for a slightly more pliant ride. The 9-5 is also marginally more refined, and has the unique trait of being big inside without feeling unwieldy on the road.

Without worrying the class leaders, the new Saab is a credible alternative to the mainstream and should prove to be a solid sales foundation on which to build. There's far too much GM DNA in the blood to make the 9-5 feel special in the way the brand's diehard fans yearn for it to, but this is certainly the best car the manufacturer could be expected to produce as it emerges from its American hangover.

Where does Saab go from here? Over to you, Spyker.

Fifth Gear overall car ratings

STYLING

The 9-5's sheer size guarantees it plenty of presence on the road, even if the rear overhang does make the car a little ungainly. Chunky styling and substantial girth give the Saab an almost American feel, which could be good if you want to distinguish yourself from the Germans in the company car park.

HANDLING

There's no mistaking the 9-5's relationship to the Vauxhall Insignia on the road, but Saab's engineers have succeeded in producing a slightly more comfortable ride without losing any poise. In fact, considering the car?s size, it handles reasonably well, only revealing its bulk when pushed. The V6 gets a more sophisticated suspension setup and all-wheel drive, but its extra traction doesn't make it anymore involving.

COMFORT

Thanks to oodles of room and decent seats, the 9-5 is certainly not an uncomfortable prospect by any standard. The ride quality might not reach the top of the class, but you do feel suitably sheltered from the road in that cavernous interior, and there's enough room in the back to stage a basketball tournament.

QUALITY & RELIABILITY

There are some niggling issues here. The Saab is not poorly made, but the sheer size of the venture seems to infect the interior with a curious sense of disjointedness. The lack of a premium budget means some questionable plastics have been asked to stretch a very long way, and we?re not the biggest fans of Saab?s blocky dash design either.

PERFORMANCE

Saab's heritage is built on turbocharged petrol engines so perhaps it's of little surprise that we found the 2.0T to be the best engine. The 296bhp V6 2.8T offered more go, but the smaller engine trumped its urgent delivery with a bit more bite and flexibility. The entry level 2.0-litre diesel is predictably adequate, with the more powerful 187bhp TTiD version offering a bit more pep.

ROOMINESS

Saab's trump card. Unless you're transporting a rugby team, no one is going to complain about being cramped in the 9-5. In terms of value per metre, the model is a five-star car and there's also a big boot in that voluminous rump.

STEREO / SAT NAV

The satellite navigation system is an expensive option at £1,200, especially as it won't appear as standard even on the higher spec models. The stereo does its job without much fuss.

RUNNING COSTS

Predictably, the cheapest 2.0-litre diesel engine is the economical pick of the bunch, with Saab claiming 53mpg for the entry-level car. Things aren't so rosy for the petrol cars, where the 2.0T pays for its performance with a 33mpg thirst. Saab's are also notorious for losing their value quicker than the Zimbabwean dollar, but a new reputation could change all that.

VALUE FOR MONEY

In terms of size, the 9-5 is a conspicuous bargain. However, if spaciousness is not your only criteria for buying a car, then there are plenty of contenders to consider. Saab's pricing has placed the car dangerously close to the BMW 5-Series and the Mercedes E-Class, both of whom offer a better driving experience. The top spec 2.8T V6 is effortlessly outgunned by similar offerings from the Germans.

ENVIRONMENT

Saab's eco score isbeing left behind by more modern engines from its rivals. As it's meant to appeal to fleet buyers, the base diesel emerges with the lowest CO2 emissions at 139g/km. However you can do much better elsewhere.

This review has been tagged with: Saab | Saab 9-5

There are 16 variants of the 9-5

9-5 variants Price (£) Fuel type Engine
size (cc)
CO2 emission
(g/km)
Vector SE 2.0 TiD 4dr £26,995 1956 125
Vector SE 1.6T 4dr £27,275 1598 178
Vector SE 2.0 TTiD 4dr £28,495 1956 142
Vector SE 2.0 TiD Auto 4dr £28,640 1956 171
Vector SE 2.0T 4dr £28,680 1998 181
Vector SE 2.0T Auto 4dr £30,325 1998 204
Vector SE 2.0 TTiD XWD 4dr £30,785 1956 170
Vector SE 2.0T XWD 4dr £30,965 1998 196
Aero 2.0 TTiD 4dr £30,995 1956 142
Aero 2.0T 4dr £31,180 1998 181
Vector SE 2.0T XWD Auto 4dr £32,480 1998 215
Aero 2.0T Auto 4dr £32,825 1998 204
Aero 2.0 TTiD XWD 4dr £33,285 1956 170
Aero 2.0T XWD 4dr £33,465 1998 196
Aero 2.0T XWD Auto 4dr £34,980 1998 215
Aero 2.8T XWD 4dr £37,995 2792 234
 

Average

3

User reviews (8)

Leave a review

SaabCrus
3

If only you could use the pictures of the new 9-5, not the previous generation. :-)

Report as inappropriate
Eirik99t
1

You've managed to use photos of the Saab 9-5 from 2006 to a review of the new 2010 9-5. I can't understand how that's even possible! That doesn't make sense at all, and I think it reveals some seriously bad journalism work... It wouldn't surprise me if the whole review is based on those photos alone.

Report as inappropriate
mcwill
4

I've been driving a 9-5 2.0T XWD for three weeks now, and wouldn't hesitate to recommend it. Yes it is a large car, but feels smaller on the road. I would put handling at 4/5, but that could be the XWD effect over the review model. Sat Nav is average, but in addition to the NAV unit you also get a colour multimedia unit with ipod integration and hard disc music storage. Add the head up display and your NAV instructions appear in front of your eyes with a countdown bar. Not sure how that rates at 2/5 for value given that the same will cost double in a Merc. Overall I'd give this car a 4 out of 5, I'll reserve the final star for when they bring out a hatch option.

Report as inappropriate
Anton
5

I am sorry, but this review can't be taken seriously. When the review manages to use pictures of the previous 9-5 model, you have to start wondering if they have driven the new car at all. And how on earth can this review criticize the exterior and interior styling and quality of the car when their own quality control let them linkt those old pictures to this so-called review of the new car! The new Saab is great. I have driven it myself and it has a much more premium present than both the Merc E-class and the Audi A6.

Report as inappropriate
Ingemar Frykman
1

If Readers since the beginning of August has tried to make you see that all pics in this review are of the old model,and nothing have happened.......... that says a lot about your level of commitment. too bad,like the show though....

Report as inappropriate

This review has been removed.

priscilla serman
5

THE SAAB 95 IS A FANTASTIC CAR VERY UNDERSTATED! I HAVE OWNED THREE AND LOVED THEM ALSO A HUGE VOLVO FAN MUCH MORE INTERESTING THAN A BORING GERMAN CAR AND MUCH BETTER THAN AN UNRELIABLE LAND ROVER RANGE ROVER JUST SOLD MY HEAP OF JUNK L322 FOR ANOTHER SAAB 95.I VOW FROM THIS DAY NEVER TO BUY OAT BUT A SAAB OR A VOLVO TRUELY AMAZING CARS WOLF IN SHEEPS CLOTHING!

Report as inappropriate

This review is awaiting moderation.

Join Channel 5

Creating an account is free, will only take a few moments and will allow you to enjoy the full benefits of 5FWD and Channel 5:

  • Create lists of your most wanted and owned products
  • Leave article comments without having to re-enter your login details
  • Get updated with all the latest gadget and car news

Leave a comment

Please note that we will not expose your email, but we might use it to email you back. Links may be included in your comments but HTML is not permitted.
* mandatory field

* Enter your rating:

Quick car search

Find a car review

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
See all